ENDEAVOUR HILLS STAR JOURNAL
Home » Bashed to death

Bashed to death

By CASEY NEILL

A HALLAM mother of four has been jailed for four years after bashing her Noble Park landlord to death in his own home.
Kristy Robb, 28, was on 25 September convicted of the manslaughter of Alan Matthews, 69, on 30 January last year.
Justice Jack Rush on Wednesday 28 October sentenced her to four years in jail with a two and a half year non-parole period.
The judge said Robb rented a bungalow at the rear of Mr Matthews’ Henry Street property for “a matter of days” in January last year.
Justice Rush said Mr Matthews “claimed you owed him rent and, as a consequence of this, he retained some of your property”.
Robb shared a bottle of vodka and two to three cannabis joints with her boyfriend Gino Rachele, 42, before attending Mr Matthews’ property about 2.45am on 30 January to retrieve school uniform items for her children.
Justice Rush accepted the timing was to avoid Mr Matthews and “there was no planning in your actions”.
Mr Matthews heard Robb and Rachele break into the bungalow and confronted Robb in the lounge room.
They argued and fought before Rachele grabbed the victim from behind and took him to the floor.
Robb left the property and Rachele soon followed.
Mr Matthews suffered several lacerations to his head and a fractured sternum, called triple zero at 2.53am and stated he had been “bashed by a woman and a bloke”.
Police found him dead in his bathroom at 3.32am.
Justice Rush said Mr Matthews “suffered cardiac arrest as a consequence of the stress of the assaults and potentially from loss of blood”.
He said the injuries from Robb’s assault were not in themselves life-threatening, plus there was evidence that Rachele played a greater role in Mr Matthews’ injuries than he admitted at trial.
“I am not satisfied beyond reasonable doubt that you are responsible for the fractured sternum,” he told Robb.
Justice Rush said Robb had a “tumultuous upbringing”.
Forensic psychologist Pamela Matthews diagnosed her with partial post-traumatic stress disorder and major depressive disorder.
“It was her view that your outbursts of volatile anger, anxiety and distress arising from this mental condition were significant contributing factors of your offending,” Justice Rush said.
Robb has prior convictions for theft, threats to kill, assault and resisting police and has four children, including four-month-old Alexander.
“Your prospects of rehabilitation are reasonably strong, but they are highly dependent upon and strengthened if you were to be granted continued custody of Alexander,” Justice Rush said.
He took into account Robb’s recent attendance at an anger management course and drug and alcohol counselling in reaching his sentence.
Rachele was on 3 September sentenced to a one-year community corrections order after pleading guilty to one charge of recklessly causing injury and false imprisonment.

Digital Editions


  • Shot fired in e-scooter dispute

    Shot fired in e-scooter dispute

    A drug-addled man who rammed open a factory gate and fired a gun near a business owner after a dispute over an e-scooter purchase has…

More News

  • Hill responds to TAHA furore

    Hill responds to TAHA furore

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 509107 Bruce MP and Assistant Citizenship, Customs and Multicultural Affairs Minister JULIAN HILL has come under fire for his 2025 election funding pledge to…

  • The Maze continues to confound

    The Maze continues to confound

    An iconic Springvale community-artwork from the 1990s has journeyed from Greater Dandenong’s archives back into the public imagination at Walker Street Gallery and Art Centre. The Maze was a huge…

  • Market future vision unveiled

    Market future vision unveiled

    A new 20-year vision for Dandenong Market and its surrounds has been unveiled, including an urban plaza, apartment towers and better connection with Palm Plaza and Dandenong Square. Greater Dandenong…

  • Violent home invasion – after 48 cans

    Violent home invasion – after 48 cans

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 481350 An armed, homeless man who stormed into a Dandenong hotel room to bash a stranger after a brief spat is facing automatic deportation.…

  • Shy stray cat finds forever home in adoption drive

    Shy stray cat finds forever home in adoption drive

    A behaviour cat, Baneberry found his forever home in the ‘Mission Adoptable’ effort to boost adoptions by animal shelters. Baneberry was brought into the Australian Animal Protection Shelter Keysborough as…

  • Cocaine trafficker sprung by hotel cleaner

    Cocaine trafficker sprung by hotel cleaner

    Purchase this photo from Pic Store: 260279 A 20-year-old Narre Warren man has been jailed for at least two years after a cleaner spotted cash and a large stash of…

  • Footy test for new Metro Tunnel routes

    Footy test for new Metro Tunnel routes

    The Metro Tunnel’s ‘Big Switch’ is set for a test as South East footy fans converge on Marvel Stadium and the MCG for AFL’s opening round. Extra train services are…

  • What’s on

    What’s on

    Harmony Festival Live multicultural performances, traditional dances, interactive workshops, and a variety of food vendors to celebrate Casey’s rich cultural diversity. – Saturday 7 March 12pm-6pm at Greg Clydesdale Square,…

  • Driver killed in Police Road crash

    Driver killed in Police Road crash

    A female driver has died in a crash on Police Road in Mulgrave this afternoon (4 March). Police say a car reportedly left the road and crashed into a tree…

  • No appetite for South-East ‘super council’: Tan

    No appetite for South-East ‘super council’: Tan

    Discussion has emerged around amalgamating local government into “super councils”, with proponents citing financial strain and economies of scale, while a former local mayor argues that “local government should stay…